HomeAll postsAsh by Malinda Lo

Ash by Malinda Lo

Ash by Malinda Lo

a review by Nalini Haynes

Ash is a Cinderella story set in a fantasy world with a strong resemblance to the movie Ever After without some of the overt fan-services that included cameos from the like of Leonardo da Vinci. Aisling, nick-named Ash, is a young girl whose mother recently died. True to form, her father soon leaves for a long trip to the city, returning prematurely with a new wife and two step-children, before dying himself.  Ash is swiftly reduced to the status of a servant in her stepmother’s household.  When Ash grows into a young adult, there is a prince on the lookout for a wife and  stepsister on the lookout for a suitable – and profitable – match.

The differences between the original and this story make this novel both memorable and worth reading.  Ash isn’t on the lookout for a prince to rescue her as the damsel in distress; instead Ash is attracted to the Huntress, a notable figure in the royal court.  Ash’s fairy godmother is more of a fairy godfather except he’s been cursed to love a human girl, Ash herself.

Exposition is rather more of a feature of this novel than I usually like but it felt fitting.  Some fairy stories I read as a child likewise used exposition instead of ‘show don’t tell’.  I felt the author cheated a little: Clara was revealed as the sympathetic sister via exposition and well towards the end of the novel.  On a scale of one to ten, however, I think my criticisms are on the picky side.

While I appreciate sexytimes as much as the next person, I do enjoy a more conservative romance with a focus on the dance culminating in resolution, like Ash, instead of numerous sex scenes.

Ash is listed on Dymocks’ website (an Australian bookseller) as children’s fiction: I would generally disagree with this classification as I think romance belongs more in Young Adult, but this novel is so sweet and chaste that it is suitable for a child.

Overall this is a very promising first novel for a non-traditional author.  Highly recommended as a fairytale retelling.  A must for young teens growing up in the LGBT community as members and supporters; there is not enough of this style of fiction to build bridges and affirm relationships across people groups.

Previous article
Next article
Nalini is an award-winning writer and artist as well as managing editor of Dark Matter Zine.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

[mailerlite_form form_id=1]